Fishizzle Sportfishing Charters Customer Reviews

Name: Fishizzle Sportfishing Charters
Brand: Fishizzle Sportfishing Charters
Rating: 5 (24 reviews)

100% would recommend

5/5

From 24
verified reviews

Jack AI Customer Experience Snapshot

Captain Todd and his crew consistently deliver exceptional fishing results, with customers catching everything from sharks and cobia to grouper, snapper, and sailfish. Reviews highlight impressive catches including six sharks in one trip, a 7-foot sailfish, multiple species like strawberry grouper and blackfin tuna, and even encounters with goliath grouper. Todd's expertise shines through in challenging conditions, successfully putting clients on fish even during slow bites and muddy waters, while his knowledge extends to targeting seasonal species like mahi-mahi. Customers consistently praise the crew's entertaining personalities and dedication to making every trip memorable. Grey Beard and Johnny Cakes are frequently mentioned for their humor and high energy, keeping everyone laughing while maintaining productive fishing. The team excels with first-time anglers and young fishermen, taking time to teach techniques and ensure everyone feels included. Many guests establish this as an annual tradition and return for multiple trips, with several reviews specifically noting repeat bookings.

AI-generated from the text of customer reviews

Sharks

Sailfish

Grouper

Entertaining Crew

Repeat Customers

Challenging Conditions

Teaching Techniques

Annual Tradition

Photos from Real Customers

See all images

One person fishing in an unknown location

Cero Mackerel and Bluefish caught by a fisherman

Three people enjoy a successful fishing trip

Anglers reeling in a great catch on the water

A fisherman and their catch on the water

A great catch - 1 big fish, 2 people enjoying fishing

Two people fishing at an unknown location

Great Barracuda fish caught by two people fishing

Blackfin tuna fishing in unknown location

Four blackfin tuna caught in unknown location during fishing trip

6 people fishing at an undisclosed location

Scenic fishing spot at undisclosed location

Three anglers fishing at an undisclosed location

Majestic Atlantic Sailfish caught while fishing

Most Reviewed Trip

Book Your Next Trip With Us

All Reviews

Vernon S

October 11, 2025

Trip - on October 11, 2025

Captain Todd and his crew were outstanding. We probably caught around 250 fish and kept 48—an incredible day all around. Highly recommend!

Was this helpful ?

Emily T

October 2, 2025

Trip - on October 2, 2025

Everything was excellent. My only small suggestion would be quicker responses to messages through the app. We caught a ton of fish and had a fantastic time! Thanks again!

Was this helpful ?

Andy G

July 25, 2025

Trip - on July 25, 2025

From clear directions and communication to the fishing itself and cleaning the catch afterward, the crew took great care of my two sons and me. The fishing was awesome and the whole experience was fantastic. If you’re considering booking with these guys, just do it! 🫶

Was this helpful ?

Ryne M

July 1, 2025

Trip - on July 1, 2025

Captain and mate were friendly, professional, and clearly knew their stuff. The boat itself is a classic and all the gear was top-notch. I’ve been on a lot of charters, and this one ranks right up there with the best. They were great with my 12-year-old son and 13-year-old nephew, too. We were given the choice to stay nearshore for more steady action or head offshore to look for Mahi. We decided on Mahi, and while we landed four really nice ones, the crew worked hard the entire four hours—baiting hooks, setting lines, and keeping us fishing the whole time. It was a great day on the water. Like any large fishing boat, there were some exhaust fumes, but there was plenty of space and comfort for a group of six (even more). Overall, a fantastic charter experience.

Was this helpful ?

Andrew C

June 24, 2025

Trip - on June 24, 2025

Captain Todd took us out on a windy day and still made it an excellent trip. He navigated us right into blue water with confidence, while the mate kept everything rigged perfectly and kept us laughing the entire time. We landed about twenty throwbacks and four keeper Mahi Mahi, exactly what we asked to target. It was a great experience from start to finish. The mate even turned our biggest fish into a Gyotaku print and framed it for us to take home, which was such a cool touch. And being able to bike from our rental to the dock, spend the day catching fish, then ride back with around 12 pounds of fresh Mahi fillets felt pretty perfect. Highly recommend—10/10 day on the water.

Was this helpful ?

Kim W

May 30, 2025

Trip - on May 30, 2025

The crew was wonderful, and we had an amazing time. The weather was perfect, we caught plenty of fish, enjoyed a great lunch afterward, and still had enough to take home. Can’t wait for the next trip! We highly recommend this charter!

Was this helpful ?

Nicole G

May 24, 2025

Trip - on May 24, 2025

Some people like their jobs, but Gibby truly loves fishing—and it shows in every incredible day on the water. He shares fishing stories, offers great tips, and is by far the funniest person on board. Thank you, Gibby, for making our son’s birthday so special!

Was this helpful ?

John C

May 2, 2025

Trip - on May 2, 2025

I had a great time and made this an annual tradition. I wouldn’t miss it for the world with these guys.

Was this helpful ?

Martin M

March 22, 2025

Trip - on March 22, 2025

Great host and an amazing time. We caught sharks and cobia, and have been talking about the trip for hours. Plus, we got plenty of photos to remember the experience. This BASS guy had a lot of fun!

Was this helpful ?

Nate V

March 7, 2025

Trip - on March 7, 2025

Five friends joined Capt. Todd and GB for a day on the water. We caught plenty of fish and shared lots of laughs. Highly recommend!

Was this helpful ?

Kim W

February 27, 2025

Trip - on February 27, 2025

This was our second trip, and we had a fantastic time. The crew was amazing! We’ll definitely be back for another trip.

Was this helpful ?

Matthew K

November 29, 2024

Trip - on November 29, 2024

We brought two young adults along and caught a ton of fish. The four of us caught nearly everything in the sea. Catching six sharks was a blast, though we lost a seventh to a huge hammerhead—an unforgettable moment. The crew and captain were knowledgeable and attentive throughout. After returning to the mainland, we had our snappers blackened and fried at a great restaurant by the dock. We caught over 100 edible fish but only kept enough to enjoy right away. Highly recommend the Lucky Charm Crew. Thank you!

Was this helpful ?

Top Key West FL Fishing Charters

Customer Reviews for Fishizzle Sportfishing Charters

At Fishizzle Sportfishing Charters in Key West, FL, we pride ourselves on delivering an exceptional fishing experience for all of our guests. Our customers consistently rave about the unforgettable memories they’ve made while fishing with Captain Todd Ermisch and his crew. Whether you’re enjoying a half-day inshore fishing trip or an exciting full-day offshore fishing adventure, the reviews speak for themselves. From the family-friendly atmosphere to the high-quality fishing gear and expert local knowledge, our guests appreciate the attention to detail and personalized service that make our Key West FL fishing charters stand out.

Why Choose Fishizzle Sportfishing Charters?

Our guests highlight the fun, professional, and friendly environment that Fishizzle Sportfishing Charters offers. Many mention how they’ve enjoyed targeting Mahi Mahi, Snapper, Sharks, and other iconic species in the waters around Key West. Family fishing charters in Key West are particularly popular, with parents and kids alike praising the experience. Whether it’s your first time fishing or you’re a seasoned angler, our reviews emphasize the memorable, exciting, and successful trips our customers consistently have. Explore our reviews to see why Fishizzle Sportfishing Charters is the top choice for Key West FL fishing charters.