Top-Rated Key West Reef Fishing | Fishizzle Charters

Published Date: July 16, 2025
Fishing

Key West, FL
$950 - $1,400 price range

Summary

Get ready for an action-packed morning on the water with this 4-hour reef fishing trip out of Key West. You'll be trolling the productive fishing grounds just offshore, targeting a variety of species like Snapper, Barracuda, Mackerel, and even sharks. Your experienced captain might also drop anchor to focus on Yellowtail Snapper, Mutton Snapper, or Grouper. It's the perfect length trip if you want to experience Key West fishing without committing a full day. The crew provides all the gear you need - rods, reels, bait, tackle, and fishing licenses are covered. Just bring along some snacks and drinks to keep you fueled up. Whether you're new to saltwater fishing or an old pro, you're in for some solid action in the clear blue waters. With room for up to 6 guests, it's a great way to make some fishing memories with family or friends in one of Florida's top fishing destinations.

Top-Rated Key West Reef Fishing | Fishizzle Charters

Reef Fishing Action

null

null

Photograph of an Atlantic Sailfish measuring 22 inches, caught while fishing in Key West

null

6 wahoo fish caught while fishing in Key West

Bright mahi-mahi and shiny tuna catch.

Key West Morning Reef Fishing: 4-Hour Action

Get ready to kick off your day with some serious rod-bending action on this 4-hour morning reef fishing trip in Key West. Whether you're a seasoned angler or just getting your feet wet, Captain Todd and the Fishizzle crew will put you on the fish for a half-day of non-stop excitement. We'll be targeting the productive reef areas just off the coast, where snappers, groupers, and other hard-fighting species are waiting to test your skills.

What to Expect on the Water

As soon as we clear the harbor, it's time to get those lines wet. We'll start by trolling along the reef edge, giving you a shot at hooking into some speedy barracuda or hard-hitting mackerel. If the bite is on, we might even tangle with a toothy shark! Once we find a hot spot, we'll drop anchor and switch to bottom fishing. This is where the real fun begins - you'll be pulling up tasty yellowtails, beefy mutton snappers, and maybe even a bruiser grouper. The Fishizzle team provides all the gear, bait, and licenses, so you just need to bring your game face (and don't forget some snacks and drinks to keep your energy up).

Rigs and Tactics for Reef Success

We use a mix of techniques to maximize your catch. For trolling, we'll set up with diving plugs and spoons that mimic baitfish. When we anchor up, it's all about getting your bait down to where the big boys are hanging out. We'll rig you up with circle hooks and just enough weight to hold bottom in the current. The key is to keep a tight line and be ready for that telltale thump when a fish takes the bait. Don't set the hook too hard – let the circle hook do its job, and before you know it, you'll be cranking up dinner!

Why Anglers Keep Coming Back

"Excellent experience all around! Todd was a great captain! Highly recommend!" - Christina Ernst "We had two great trips the week with Captain Kevin. He does a great job of keeping lines baited and putting you on fish. We had a great time!" - Melissa Grier "Perfect 4 hour trip on the water with Capt. Todd! Even in the windy conditions he put us on the fish. Highly recommend." - Kyle

Species You'll Want to Hook

Silk Snapper: These deep-water beauties are a prized catch off Key West. Known for their striking pink coloration and firm, white flesh, silk snappers put up a good fight and make for excellent table fare. They tend to hang out in schools near rocky bottom structures, so when you find one, get ready for some fast action!

Mutton Snapper: A favorite among local anglers, mutton snappers are known for their intelligence and hard-fighting nature. These copper-colored fish can grow to impressive sizes, with some specimens topping 20 pounds. They're most active during the warmer months and love to hit live baits fished near the bottom.

Gag Grouper: If you're looking for a real workout, hooking into a gag grouper will definitely do the trick. These powerful fish are ambush predators, using their large mouths to inhale prey. They love structure and can be found around reefs and wrecks. The challenge is getting them away from their hidey-holes before they can break you off!

Grey Snapper: Also known as mangrove snappers, these feisty fish are abundant in the Keys and provide consistent action year-round. They might not be the biggest fish in the sea, but what they lack in size they make up for in numbers and fight. Grey snappers are perfect for anglers of all skill levels and make for some fantastic fish tacos.

Goliath Grouper: The true giants of the reef, goliath groupers can grow to mammoth proportions – we're talking hundreds of pounds! While we practice catch-and-release with these protected behemoths, hooking into one is an experience you'll never forget. It's like trying to reel in a Volkswagen! The sheer power of these fish is awe-inspiring, and they're a bucket list catch for many anglers.

Time to Book Your Spot

This 4-hour morning trip is the perfect way to scratch that fishing itch without taking up your whole day. You'll be back at the dock in time for lunch, with plenty of fish stories (and hopefully some fresh fillets) to show for it. Whether you're a local looking for a quick fishing fix or a visitor wanting to experience the legendary Key West fishery, Captain Todd and the Fishizzle team will make sure you have a blast. Don't let this opportunity slip away – spots fill up fast, especially during peak season. Give us a call or book online today, and get ready to make some waves!

Customer Reviews

Todds Top Notch Trip

Excellent experience all around! Todd was a great captain! Highly recommend!

Christina Ernst Santaspirt

February 1, 2025

Kevins Fishing Magic

We had two great trips the week with Captain Kevin. He does a great job of keeping lines baited and putting you on fish. We had a great time!

Melissa Grier Schneider

May 17, 2024

Windy Win with Todd

Perfect 4 hour trip on the water with Capt. Todd! Even in the windy conditions he put us on the fish. Highly recommend.

Kyle Sargent

June 24, 2022

Matt Johnny Wonder

Matt and Johnny made the fishing experience wonderful

Carol Witt

April 22, 2022

Todds Fantastic Fish

Amazing day on the water!!!!!! Captain Todd did a fantastic job putting us on fish, look forward to next year!!!!

Justin Staats

February 28, 2022

Todds Grouper Bonanza

Todd was great. We put so many fish in the boat we lost count, to include a goliath grouper.

Robert Crowe

February 7, 2022

Learn more about the species

Gag Grouper

Gag Groupers are hard-fighting fish that love structure. They typically run 20-30 inches long, but can reach over 4 feet and weigh up to 80 pounds. Look for them around rocky bottoms, reefs, and shipwrecks. Young Gags stick to inshore areas, while adults prefer offshore haunts. They're ambush predators, so we'll target them near ledges and drop-offs where they lurk. Live bait like mullet or pinfish works best, but cut squid or crab can do the trick too. Gags are known for their powerful initial run. Once hooked, they'll try to dive back into their rocky lairs. The key is to keep your rod low and reel fast to turn their heads. Don't give them an inch of slack or they'll break you off on the structure. These fish are prized for their white, flaky meat. Just remember, they grow slowly and can live up to 30 years, so we practice careful catch-and-release with the big ones to keep the population healthy.

Goliath Grouper

Goliath Groupers are the giants of the reef. These massive fish can grow up to 8 feet long and weigh 800 pounds. They're usually a mottled tan and grey color, with tiny eyes and broad heads. You'll find them in shallow tropical waters, often around artificial reefs and shipwrecks. They can even tolerate brackish water. Goliaths are ambush predators, so we look for them near structure where they can hide. Fishing for Goliaths is catch-and-release only - they're protected due to overfishing. But hooking one is an experience you won't forget. They put up an intense, if short-lived fight. That first pull can yank you right off the boat if you're not ready. If we target them, we use extra-heavy gear - think 600-pound test line and 20/0 circle hooks. The key is getting them away from the structure before they can break you off. It's all about the thrill and the photo op with these gentle giants.

Grey Snapper

Grey Snappers, also called Mangrove Snappers, are a blast to catch. They're usually 10-14 inches long, but offshore they can hit 20 pounds. Look for their greyish-red color and the dark stripe across their eye. These guys love structure - you'll find them around docks, piers, and mangroves. They're opportunistic feeders, most active at night. We'll use live shrimp or small baitfish, letting it sink near the bottom where they hang out. Grey Snappers are known for their swift, darting strikes. They're not the biggest fighters, but they make up for it in numbers and taste. Their white, flaky meat is a local favorite. Here's a tip: when you're fishing for them, don't jerk the rod when you feel a bite. Just reel in slowly to set the hook. These guys are smart and can be finicky, so a subtle approach often works best.

Mutton Snapper

Mutton Snappers are a prized catch here in Key West. They're usually 15-20 inches long, but can get up to 37 inches and weigh over 30 pounds. Look for their olive color and distinctive blue lines near their eyes. These guys love hanging around reefs and mangroves, often in water 80-150 feet deep. They're most active at dawn and dusk, which is when we'll target them. Muttons are opportunistic feeders, so we'll use fresh bait like shrimp, crabs, or small fish. Anglers love Muttons for their fight and their flavor. They're known as "nice fighters" compared to other snappers, giving you a good tussle on lighter tackle. Here's a local tip: when fishing in shallow water, let your bait drift in the chum slick with little to no weight. Muttons can't resist it. And when you see that flash of pink coming up from the deep blue, you know you've got one on the line.

Silk Snapper

Silk Snappers are deep-water fish, usually hanging out 400-500 feet down. They're a beautiful reddish-pink color, getting lighter towards the belly. Most are around 17 inches long, but they can grow up to 32 inches. These guys love to eat crustaceans and smaller fish. We typically target them at night when they move to shallower waters. Fresh bait is key - try kahawai, mackerel, or squid. The trick is to make your bait look as natural as possible. Don't impale it on the hook, let it move freely. Silk Snappers put up a good fight and taste great. Some folks say the deeper you catch them, the better they taste. Just be careful if you're reeling one in from way down - their swim bladders can expand, so we often need to help them back down if we're releasing them. Remember, in some areas there are restrictions during spawning season. But when we can catch them, they're a real treat for the dinner table.

About the Fishizzle Sportfishing

Vehicle Guest Capacity: 6

Manufacturer Name: Caterpillar

Maximum Cruising Speed: 13

Number of Engines: 2

Horsepower per Engine: 350

Ready for an awesome morning of fishing in Key West? This 4-hour trip takes you right to the action along the reef. You'll be trolling for snapper, barracuda, mackerel, and maybe even some sharks. Or, we can drop anchor and go after yellowtail snapper, mutton snapper, and grouper. It's a great way to pack in some solid fishing without taking up your whole day. Your captain and first mate have you covered with all the gear – rods, reels, bait, tackle, and fishing licenses. Just bring along your favorite snacks and drinks, and you're set. Whether you're new to saltwater fishing or coming back for more, you'll find plenty of action in these clear Key West waters. With room for up to 6 people, it's perfect for a small group or family outing. Get ready to reel in some fish and make some cool memories out on the water!

Sitemap